Penn Badgley is a sweet-cheeked, affable actor, yet he also seems to have a penchant for roles that keep you guessing. His most recent project, "You," started on Lifetime for its first season but is now in the very capable hands of Netflix, who will develop at least a season 2. The show finds Badgley hyper-obsessed with his girlfriend, and viewers were quick to point out the reason for the show's title: "I'm watching 'You.'" Creepy, right? Find out which version of Badgley you are.