While the obsession with true crime has not slowed down in the slightest (if anything, we’re now way too open about how much we enjoy learning about high-profile cases and heinous criminals), there are other ways to get your creepy fix this month. Podcasts are special in that while you can learn about real-life cases, you can also simply listen to some good, old-fashioned scary stories. The eeriness of having the tales narrated right into your ears creates a different level of spook than your average horror movie. These seven podcasts skip the truth and go straight for the fictional or supernatural, but they’ll still keep you up at night. Vote the creepiest to the top!